The short answer
Psychologists’ views on Stoicism are mixed but mostly respectful. Many therapists see it as a historical ancestor of cognitive therapies and find some Stoic exercises useful. Researchers have begun to study Stoic-based programmes, but the evidence is still early and limited. Critics also point out that the popular image of Stoicism can encourage people to suppress feelings, and that it does not replace professional mental health care.
Stoic roots of CBT and REBT
The clearest link between Stoicism and psychology is in cognitive-behavioural approaches. These therapies rest on the idea that the way we interpret events affects how we feel and act.
- Albert Ellis, who developed Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) in the 1950s, said he drew on ancient philosophers, especially Epictetus. A line from Epictetus’s Handbook, that people are disturbed not by things but by their views of them, is often cited as a forerunner of Ellis’s thinking.
- Aaron Beck, who developed cognitive therapy, also acknowledged the ancient Stoics as part of the philosophical background to his approach.
- Donald Robertson, a psychotherapist and author, has written about the connections between Stoic philosophy and cognitive therapy, and has helped bring them to a wider audience.
This is a link of ideas and inspiration. Modern cognitive therapy is a structured clinical method with its own research base, and it is not simply Stoicism repackaged.
Where Stoic practices and therapy techniques overlap
Some Stoic exercises resemble techniques used in therapy. The parallels are approximate, not exact.
| Stoic practice | Similar idea in modern psychology |
|---|---|
| Separating what is up to you from what is not | Distinguishing controllable from uncontrollable problems; acceptance-based coping |
| Examining your first impression before assenting to it | Identifying and questioning automatic thoughts |
| Evening review of the day | Reflective journaling and thought records |
| Negative visualisation | Mentally rehearsing difficulties; anticipating setbacks |
| The view from above | Cognitive distancing and perspective-taking |
To see the first of these in detail, read our article on the dichotomy of control.
What does the research show?
Research on Stoicism as an intervention is still developing. Some points are reasonable to state:
- Programmes exist. Groups of academics and practitioners, including a team connected with the University of Exeter, have organised events such as “Stoic Week,” a short online course in which participants try Stoic exercises and complete wellbeing questionnaires.
- Early results are modestly encouraging. Small studies of this kind have generally reported improvements in measures such as wellbeing or emotional resilience.
- The evidence has limits. Many participants chose to take part, many studies are short, and some lack a rigorous control group. That makes it difficult to say how much of any benefit comes from the Stoic content itself.
Be wary of articles that claim Stoicism “rewires the brain” or is proven to treat anxiety and depression. Those claims go beyond what current research supports. Studies of CBT itself are far more extensive, but that evidence applies to CBT and does not automatically carry over to Stoicism.
Criticisms and limits
Psychologists and philosophers have raised several concerns:
- Emotional suppression. If “being Stoic” is understood as hiding or bottling up feelings, that is a concern. Research on habitual emotional suppression has often linked it to poorer outcomes in various settings. The ancient Stoics did not intend suppression, but popular versions can drift in that direction.
- Oversimplifying control. The line between what is and is not in your control is not always clear, and some influences, such as upbringing, biology and social conditions, shape what is possible for us.
- Individual focus. An emphasis on adjusting your response may understate the role of social and systemic problems that call for action and change, not only acceptance.
- Not suited to every difficulty. Stoic self-examination may help with everyday stress. It is not designed to address severe depression, trauma or other clinical conditions.
Stoicism is not a substitute for professional care
If you are experiencing persistent low mood, anxiety, thoughts of self-harm or other serious difficulties, please speak to a qualified health professional or a local crisis service. Stoic exercises can sit alongside professional treatment for some people, but they should not replace it. Some therapists incorporate Stoic ideas into their work, so it is reasonable to ask a clinician whether they would be useful in your case.
Using Stoic ideas sensibly
If you want to try these ideas, a few cautious principles apply:
- Treat them as tools, not rules. Try an exercise such as an evening review for a few weeks and see whether it helps.
- Don’t confuse calm with numbness. Noticing and naming a feeling is compatible with Stoic practice. Hiding it from yourself is not.
- Act where action is possible. Acceptance applies to what cannot be changed, and Stoics encouraged effort and duty in the rest.
- Get support when you need it. Friends, family and professionals are part of a good life too.
For the philosophical background, start with our pillar article on what Stoicism is. For how Stoics thought about wellbeing more broadly, see the Stoic philosophy of happiness. If you want to know where the ideas came from, our piece on the top five Stoics introduces the main figures.