The dichotomy of control in short
The dichotomy of control is the Stoic idea that some things are up to you and others are not, and that peace of mind depends on keeping the two apart. You put your effort and concern into what is up to you, mainly your own judgments, choices and actions, and you try to meet the rest with acceptance.
The idea is most closely associated with Epictetus, a Roman-era Stoic teacher. It is one of the best-known parts of Stoicism, and it works as a practical tool: a quick way to ask where your energy should go.
What Epictetus actually said
The Handbook (Enchiridion), compiled by his student Arrian, opens with this division. Epictetus says that some things are up to us and some are not. Up to us are our opinion, impulse, desire and aversion, in short, whatever is our own doing. Not up to us are our body, our property, our reputation and our public office, in short, whatever is not our own doing.
He then adds a warning: if you treat what is not up to you as if it were yours, you will be hindered and disturbed. If you correctly see what is yours and what is not, no one can force you, and no one can harm you.
Notice that the list is not about positive thinking. Epictetus is not telling you to feel upbeat. He is making a claim about where freedom and responsibility lie. Our wider guide to what Stoicism is places this idea in the context of the whole philosophy.
What is up to you and what is not
| Up to you | Not up to you |
|---|---|
| Your judgments and opinions | Other people’s opinions of you |
| Your choices and effort | The outcome of those choices |
| Your values and intentions | Other people’s actions and words |
| How you respond to events | The weather, traffic, the economy |
| What you decide to pursue or avoid | Your health, in the sense of staying well |
| Your own words and conduct | Your reputation |
Some entries on the right are partly influenced by your actions. You can look after your health, for example, but you cannot guarantee it. This is part of why the next section matters.
Up to us or control? A note on translation
“Dichotomy of control” is a modern phrase. The Greek expression Epictetus used is usually rendered as “up to us” or “in our power.” Some scholars argue that “control” is a misleading translation because it sounds absolute. “Up to us” is closer to the idea that these are the areas where our own agency is decisive. The shift is small, but it matters. Even your thoughts and feelings are not perfectly controllable. What the Stoics emphasised was that your judgments about them are yours to examine.
The archer and the reserve clause
Two classical ideas help explain how this works in practice.
The archer. Ancient accounts of Stoic ethics use the image of an archer. The archer can train, choose a target, aim carefully and release the arrow well. Whether the arrow hits depends partly on things beyond the archer, such as wind or movement. The archer’s job is to shoot as well as possible. The hit is a “preferred” outcome and is not what makes the shot a good one. Stoics used this to separate effort from result.
The reserve clause. Stoics advised pursuing goals “with reservation,” in effect adding “if nothing prevents it.” You can plan a trip, start a business or apply for a job wholeheartedly while recognising that events may intervene. The reserve clause lets you commit fully without staking your peace of mind on the outcome.
How to apply it
A simple routine can help when something is bothering you.
- Name the situation. Write down what is troubling you in one or two sentences.
- Split it in two. List which parts are up to you, such as your preparation, your words, your effort and your reaction. List which parts are not.
- Put your energy into the first list. Decide on one concrete action you can take, however small.
- Practise acceptance with the second list. Remind yourself that these parts are not yours to decide.
- Review. Later, ask whether you acted well, whatever happened.
Worked examples
- A job interview. Up to you: preparing, arriving on time, answering honestly. Not up to you: how many other candidates there are, what the interviewer decides. If you are rejected after doing your best, you have done your part.
- A critical comment from a colleague. Up to you: whether you consider the feedback fairly and how you reply. Not up to you: whether they are kind about it, or what they think of you afterwards.
- Heavy traffic. Up to you: when you leave, what you listen to, whether you stay calm. Not up to you: the traffic itself.
- A health scare. Up to you: seeking professional advice, following treatment, how you treat people around you. Not up to you: the diagnosis or the outcome. Always seek qualified medical advice, as Stoic practice is not a substitute for it.
The trichotomy of control
Some modern writers, notably William Irvine in A Guide to the Good Life, suggest a third category: things that are partly up to you. A tennis match is a typical example. You control your effort and preparation, but not the opponent or the bounce of the ball. Irvine’s approach is to set internal goals, such as playing as well as you can, instead of goals that depend on outcomes, such as winning.
The trichotomy is a modern teaching device, not ancient Stoic terminology, but many readers find it a more realistic way to apply the original idea. It is close in spirit to the archer analogy.
Common mistakes
- Treating it as “think positive.” The aim is accuracy about what is yours, not forced optimism.
- Using it to excuse inaction. The dichotomy tells you where to act. It does not tell you to give up.
- Ignoring other people. Stoicism includes duties to others. Your own actions toward them are up to you.
- Expecting perfect control of your feelings. The Stoic goal is to examine the judgments behind emotions, and not to claim mastery over every reaction.
Criticisms of the dichotomy
The idea has fair criticisms:
- It can seem fatalistic or passive. If you accept what you cannot control, will you stop trying to change unjust situations? Defenders reply that the dichotomy directs effort to where it can work, but critics say popular versions can encourage resignation.
- The line is blurry. Upbringing, biology, health and social conditions all shape what you are able to choose. Many things are partly in your power, which is part of why the trichotomy was proposed.
- It can neglect social and structural factors. Telling people to focus on their own response may understate problems that need collective or political action.
- It is not therapy. Some psychologists see value in the underlying approach, but it is not a treatment for clinical conditions. See what psychologists think of Stoicism.
Epictetus’s own answer would be that the dichotomy is a tool for clear thinking and not a reason to disengage. The Stoics were encouraged to act with justice and courage, as set out in the four Stoic virtues, and to see happiness as a result of character, as discussed in the Stoic philosophy of happiness. For the people behind the idea, see who the top five Stoics are.