Stoicism Basics

Stoicism vs. Epicureanism: Key Differences in How They Pursue a Good Life

Stoicism vs Epicureanism compared: how each school viewed pleasure, virtue, politics, the gods and death, and what they share as practical philosophies.

On this page
  1. Stoicism vs Epicureanism at a glance
  2. Two schools, one era
  3. The highest good: virtue or pleasure?
  4. What Epicureans meant by pleasure
  5. Emotions and desires
  6. Public life and friendship
  7. The universe, the gods and death
  8. What the two schools share
  9. Which one is more useful today?

Stoicism vs Epicureanism at a glance

Stoicism and Epicureanism were two of the leading philosophies of the Hellenistic world, and both began in Athens within a few decades of each other. Both offered a way to live well and to be less at the mercy of fortune. They disagreed about almost everything else.

Topic Stoicism Epicureanism
Founder Zeno of Citium Epicurus
Highest good Virtue Pleasure, understood as freedom from pain and disturbance
Role of virtue Good in itself Valuable because it supports a pleasant, untroubled life
Pleasure and pain Indifferent; not what makes life good Pleasure is the goal; pain is to be minimised
Public life Encouraged duty and civic engagement Generally advised keeping a low profile
Community Humanity as a shared community Close circle of friends
The universe Rational, ordered and providential Made of atoms and void; no divine plan
Death Natural; an indifferent Nothing to fear, since we do not experience it

Two schools, one era

Epicurus (341 to 270 BCE) founded his school in Athens around 306 BCE and taught in a house and garden, so his followers were known as “the Garden.” Zeno began teaching in the Stoa Poikile, or Painted Porch, around 300 BCE. For several centuries these two schools, together with Platonists, Aristotelians and Skeptics, competed for followers. To place Stoicism in this wider history, see what Stoicism is.

The highest good: virtue or pleasure?

The central disagreement is about what makes a life good.

For the Stoics, virtue is the only true good. Wisdom, courage, justice and temperance, which we outline in the four Stoic virtues, are valuable in themselves, whatever pleasure or pain they bring.

For Epicureans, the highest good is pleasure. Virtues such as prudence, honesty and moderation matter because they make a pleasant, calm life possible. In this sense virtue is valuable for its results, which is a very different view from the Stoic one.

Both schools used the Greek word eudaimonia, meaning flourishing, for the goal of life. The Stoic view of it is explored in the Stoic philosophy of happiness.

What Epicureans meant by pleasure

“Epicurean” is often used today to mean a lover of fine food and luxury. That is not what Epicurus taught. He described pleasure mainly as aponia (freedom from bodily pain) and ataraxia (freedom from mental disturbance). He argued that a simple life with good friends is the most reliable way to this state.

Epicurus sorted desires into groups: natural and necessary (such as food, shelter and friendship), natural but unnecessary (such as lavish meals), and empty desires (such as for fame or great wealth). He advised satisfying the first and avoiding the last, because chasing them tends to produce anxiety. Ancient critics sometimes described Epicureans as self-indulgent, but this reflects rivalry more than their own stated views.

Emotions and desires

Both schools aimed for a stable, untroubled mind, but they got there differently.

  • Stoics targeted destructive emotions by examining the judgments behind them. They did not simply suppress feelings. The Stoic goal is sometimes summarised with the Greek word apatheia, but this does not mean being unfeeling. It refers to freedom from disturbing passions.
  • Epicureans aimed for tranquility by limiting desires, avoiding unnecessary ambition, and removing groundless fears, especially fear of the gods and of death.

The Stoic technique of separating what is yours to shape from what is not is covered in our article on the dichotomy of control.

Public life and friendship

Stoics generally encouraged taking part in public life where possible and doing your duty to family, friends and the wider community. They saw humans as naturally social, and several Roman Stoics were involved in politics. Marcus Aurelius was an emperor.

Epicureans tended to advise staying out of politics, which they saw as a source of anxiety and rivalry. They placed great value on friendship, and Epicurus regarded it as one of the greatest sources of security and happiness. Stoics also valued friendship, but they framed it within a broader sense of duty and community.

The universe, the gods and death

Their views of the universe differ sharply.

  • Stoic physics describes a single, ordered cosmos pervaded by a rational principle, often called logos, nature, providence or Zeus. Living well means living in harmony with it.
  • Epicurean physics is atomist: the world consists of atoms moving in empty space. Epicureans believed in gods, but held that the gods are untroubled and do not intervene in human affairs. They saw no reason to fear divine punishment.

On death, Epicurus argued that since we do not experience our own death, it is nothing to us. The Stoics treated death as part of nature and used reminders of mortality to focus attention on living well. Both aimed to reduce the fear of death, by different arguments.

What the two schools share

Despite their rivalry, they have common ground:

  • Both were materialist in the sense that they rejected Plato’s separate world of ideal forms.
  • Both saw philosophy as a practical way of life, a kind of medicine for the soul, not only theory.
  • Both prized self-sufficiency and aimed for mental tranquility regardless of fortune.
  • Both urged people to examine their beliefs and desires.

Seneca, a Roman Stoic, quoted Epicurus with approval in some of his letters, which suggests that the boundary was not always rigid in practice.

Which one is more useful today?

That depends on what you are looking for. Stoicism may appeal if you want a framework for dealing with setbacks, acting on your values and fulfilling your duties. Epicureanism may appeal if you want to simplify your life, prize friendships and reduce anxiety about ambition and status.

Many modern readers draw on both. If you are just starting with Stoicism, see our introduction to the top five Stoics for suggestions on where to begin reading.

The complete guide to stoicism basics

What Is Stoicism? Origins, Founders and Core Ideas
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →