Inner Freedom

Stoic Inner Freedom: Psychological Freedom in Philosophy

What psychological freedom means in philosophy, how the Stoics placed it in our judgments rather than our circumstances, and how it compares with other views.

On this page
  1. What psychological freedom means in philosophy
  2. What “psychological” means in simple words
  3. Freedom in philosophy: the main senses
  4. How ancient thinkers located freedom
  5. The Stoic answer: freedom lives in judgment
  6. Two Stoic voices: Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius
  7. What freedom means in psychology
  8. Limits and criticisms
  9. A few ways to practise
  10. Where to go next

What psychological freedom means in philosophy

In philosophy, psychological freedom usually means being free in your own mind: not being driven by impulses, fears, or unexamined opinions, and being able to act on your own judgment. It is a different question from whether you are free from other people, such as rulers, employers, or owners.

The Stoics gave one of the most influential answers. In their view, freedom is mainly a matter of how you judge and respond to what happens, because your judgments are the one thing no one else can directly take from you. That idea is the thread running through this section of the site.

What “psychological” means in simple words

“Psychological” simply means “to do with the mind”: thoughts, feelings, motives, and habits. So psychological freedom is freedom as it is experienced and exercised in the mind, as opposed to legal or physical freedom. A person can be legally free and still feel ruled by anxiety, anger, or the need for approval. A person can also be physically constrained and still keep a steady, self-directed mind. Ancient philosophers took both possibilities seriously.

Freedom in philosophy: the main senses

Philosophers use the word “freedom” in several overlapping ways:

  • Political or civic freedom: living under laws you take part in making, rather than under a master or tyrant.
  • Freedom of the will: whether our choices are genuinely ours, given causes and circumstances. This is the debate about free will and determinism.
  • Negative and positive liberty: a distinction popularised by Isaiah Berlin in the twentieth century. Negative liberty is freedom from interference. Positive liberty is the capacity to govern yourself, to be the author of your own choices.
  • Inner freedom: mastery over your own reactions and desires, so that you are not pushed around by them.

The ancient Greeks and Romans were less interested in the modern free-will problem and more interested in the last two senses: what it takes to be self-governing, and what keeps a person enslaved even when no one is holding the chains.

How ancient thinkers located freedom

Several ancient strands feed into the Stoic view, and each has its own article here:

The Stoic answer: freedom lives in judgment

What is up to us

The Stoic philosopher Epictetus opens his short handbook, the Enchiridion, by dividing things into those that are up to us and those that are not. Roughly speaking, our own judgments, impulses, and desires are up to us. Our bodies, property, reputation, and the actions of other people are not fully so. Freedom, on this view, comes from placing your sense of well-being in the first group and holding the second group more loosely.

Impressions and assent

Stoics described mental life as a sequence. Something happens and strikes you as a kind of “impression.” You then either give assent to it (“yes, this is terrible”) or withhold assent. That moment of assent is where the Stoics located responsibility, and so freedom. You do not choose every impression that arises, but you have some say over what you agree to.

Passions as judgments

The Stoics held that destructive emotions, which they called passions, are not raw events that simply happen to us. They are bound up with mistaken judgments, such as treating something outside our control as a real good or a real evil. If so, then changing the judgment can loosen the emotion. Whether you accept this fully or not, it explains why Stoics spoke of freedom and emotion in the same breath.

Two Stoic voices: Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius

Epictetus, a former slave, made the case that the person who wants things outside their control is, in effect, serving whoever controls them. His argument is explored in Epictetus on freedom and why a slave can be freer than a master.

Marcus Aurelius, a Roman emperor, wrote private notes now called the Meditations, in which he describes a mind that can withdraw into itself and stay steady. That image is unpacked in the inner citadel.

What freedom means in psychology

Modern psychology does not use the Stoic vocabulary, but it has related ideas:

  • Autonomy: in self-determination theory, a sense that your actions come from your own values rather than from pressure is treated as a basic psychological need.
  • Perceived control: people generally do better when they feel some control over their circumstances, and worse when they feel helpless.
  • Reactance: people often push back when they feel their freedom is being restricted.
  • Cognitive approaches to therapy: founders of cognitive and rational-emotive therapies, such as Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck, have acknowledged the influence of Stoic ideas, especially the claim that our interpretations shape our emotions.

These are parallels, not proofs that the Stoics were right. The modern literature is nuanced, and it is not a substitute for professional care if you are struggling.

Limits and criticisms

Stoic inner freedom is not without problems, and it is fair to name them:

  • It can sound like advice to accept anything. The Stoics themselves did not recommend passivity about injustice, but the emphasis on inner response can be misused to excuse real harm.
  • Some critics think it asks too much emotional detachment, or underrates the role of the body, relationships, and circumstances in well-being.
  • Not every difficult feeling comes from a faulty judgment. Grief, trauma, and depression are not simply thinking errors, and they are often better addressed with support from other people and qualified professionals.

A few ways to practise

None of these is a cure-all. They are simply the kind of exercises Stoic writers recommended:

  1. Sort the situation. Write down what is within your control and what is not, and put your effort into the first list.
  2. Pause before assent. When something upsets you, say to yourself, “This is an impression, and I do not have to agree with it yet.”
  3. Review the day. In the evening, look back on what you did well, what you handled poorly, and what you would do differently.
  4. Ask who is steering. When you want something badly, ask whether getting it depends on someone else’s approval or action.

Where to go next

If you want to start with the people, read Epictetus on freedom and Marcus Aurelius on the inner citadel. For the philosophical background, try Aristotle’s definition of freedom, the self in ancient philosophy, and autarkeia.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →