Inner Freedom

Epictetus on Freedom: Why a Slave Can Be Freer Than a Master

Epictetus, once enslaved, argued that freedom depends on mastering your own judgments and desires. Learn his reasoning, its sources, and its limits.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Who was Epictetus?
  3. The famous quote, and what it is really from
  4. What is up to us
  5. Why a master can be a slave
  6. Why a slave can be free
  7. Does inner freedom excuse slavery?
  8. Living it: a few practices
  9. Related reading

Short answer

Epictetus argued that real freedom does not depend on your legal status but on whether you are ruled by things outside your control. Someone legally enslaved can be inwardly free if they have mastered their own desires and judgments, while a powerful master who craves wealth, fears losing status, or is mastered by anger is, in a sense, enslaved to those things.

Who was Epictetus?

Epictetus (roughly 50 to 135 CE) was born in Hierapolis in Phrygia, in what is now Turkey. He spent part of his early life as an enslaved person in Rome, in the household of a man named Epaphroditus, who is described as a freedman connected to the imperial court. Epictetus later became free and taught philosophy in Rome, and afterwards in Nicopolis in Greece, reportedly after philosophers were expelled from Rome under Emperor Domitian.

Epictetus did not write his teachings down. A student, Arrian, recorded the Discourses and compiled a short handbook, the Enchiridion. Stories about Epictetus’s leg being damaged while enslaved are traditional and not firmly verified, so they are best treated cautiously.

The famous quote, and what it is really from

Many online pages circulate versions of the line “No man is free who is not master of himself.” It is commonly attributed to Epictetus, and it does capture his thought, but the exact wording you see varies from page to page and depends on the translation. If you want to cite him, it is better to refer to a particular passage, for example the discussion “On freedom” in Book 4 of the Discourses (4.1) and Enchiridion 14, rather than rely on a meme.

What is up to us

The Enchiridion begins by separating what is up to us from what is not. Our opinions, impulses, desires, and aversions are up to us. Our bodies, possessions, reputations, and positions are not fully so, because other people or events can affect them. Freedom, for Epictetus, comes from directing your desires only at what is up to you. If you want something that someone else can grant or withhold, you have in effect given that person authority over you.

Why a master can be a slave

By this standard, a master who is dependent on others’ flattery, afraid of losing a job, or inflamed by anger is not free, because those things control him. Epictetus used the language of slavery to describe being governed by fear, craving, or the need for approval. His point was not that the master’s legal power is illusory, but that it does not solve the inner problem.

Why a slave can be free

Conversely, an enslaved person can still decide how to judge the situation. They cannot choose their circumstances, but they can choose not to be consumed by resentment, fear, or envy. In Enchiridion 14, as it is commonly paraphrased, Epictetus says that anyone who wants to be free should neither wish for nor avoid things that depend on others, or else they will be a slave to those others. This is what his own life was held up as demonstrating.

Does inner freedom excuse slavery?

No, and it would be a serious misreading to think so. The Stoics generally did not campaign to abolish slavery as an institution, which is a real limitation of the school and of the period. Still, some Stoic writing pushed in a humane direction: Seneca, in one of his letters, urged that enslaved people be treated as fellow human beings. Epictetus’s claim is about where a person’s dignity and self-command lie, not a claim that unjust bondage is acceptable. Inner freedom is not a replacement for justice.

Living it: a few practices

  1. Name the dependency. When you feel trapped, ask which outside thing you are depending on, such as someone’s approval, a promotion, or a result.
  2. Turn desire toward what you control. Redirect your aim toward your effort, honesty, and conduct rather than the outcome.
  3. Notice the impression. Before reacting to an insult or setback, recall that your reaction rests on a judgment you can examine, as described in Stoic inner freedom.
  4. Keep perspective. If your circumstances are harmful or unjust, working to change them is compatible with this approach.

Epictetus’s contrast between slavery and freedom stands out against Aristotle’s view, covered in how Aristotle defines freedom. For a Roman emperor’s version of a similar idea, see the inner citadel, and for self-reliance more broadly, autarkeia.

The complete guide to inner freedom

Stoic Inner Freedom: Psychological Freedom in Philosophy
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →