Daily Living

What did the Stoics say about discipline?

The Stoics saw discipline as doing what reason says needs doing. Here is what Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius and Seneca taught about habit, desire and self-mastery.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Discipline as doing what needs doing
  3. Habit is built by acts
  4. Self-control as one of four virtues
  5. The three disciplines of Epictetus
  6. Training for hardship
  7. Discipline without harshness
  8. Putting it into practice

The short answer

The Stoics treated discipline as the steady practice of doing what reason says needs doing, whether or not you feel like doing it. They did not use the word the way modern self-help does. Their closest ideas were self-control (one of the four virtues), training of the mind through repeated practice and the careful management of desire and judgment. Discipline, for them, served a goal: living virtuously and with clear judgment, not just being productive.

Discipline as doing what needs doing

The best-known passage comes from the Meditations. Marcus Aurelius, writing to himself, imagines the moment of struggling to get out of bed (Book 5, opening). His point is that he is getting up to do the work of a human being, which means acting as a rational and social creature, and that staying warm under the blankets is not what he is here for. It is a private pep talk, not an instruction to anyone else, but it captures the idea well: the task comes first, and the mood doesn’t get a vote.

Note that Marcus is not saying that comfort is bad. He is saying that the question “do I feel like it?” is not the question that decides what a person should do.

Habit is built by acts

Epictetus gave the most direct practical advice. In the Discourses (2.18), he says that every habit and faculty is maintained and strengthened by the corresponding actions, so that walking becomes a habit by walking and running by running. His conclusion for anyone who wants a trait is simple: if you want something to become a habit, do it. If you want to stop, don’t do it, and train yourself in the opposite.

He applies this to character too. Someone who gets angry regularly is rehearsing anger. Someone who practices patience is becoming more patient. This is part of why Stoic practice emphasizes small, repeated exercises rather than dramatic resolutions.

Self-control as one of four virtues

The Stoics named four cardinal virtues: wisdom, justice, courage and self-control (also translated as temperance or moderation). Self-control is the one most closely linked to what we now call discipline: governing appetites and impulses rather than being governed by them. But the Stoics held that the virtues are connected. Self-control without wisdom could be stubbornness, and without justice it could serve selfish ends. Discipline, in their view, should be aimed at good things.

Epictetus is also recorded as saying that no one is free who is not master of themselves. This is a theme rather than a slogan: freedom comes from not being pushed around by passing wants and fears.

The three disciplines of Epictetus

In modern Stoic teaching, “discipline” also has a second meaning: a field of training. Following an interpretation of Epictetus popularized by the historian Pierre Hadot, students often speak of three disciplines:

  1. Desire. Train yourself to want only what is up to you, such as acting well, and to hold external things like money, status and reputation more loosely. The Stoics called these “indifferents,” some of which may be preferable but none of which determine your worth.
  2. Action. Train yourself to act fairly and responsibly toward others, doing your duties in family, work and community, even when you can’t guarantee the outcome.
  3. Assent. Train yourself not to accept first impressions automatically. Before agreeing that “this person is against me” or “this is a disaster,” examine whether the impression is accurate.

Taken together, they cover what to want, how to act and how to judge.

Training for hardship

Seneca recommended practicing discomfort in advance. In his Letter 18, he suggests setting aside a few days of very plain food and simple clothing and asking whether this is the condition you feared. The goal is to find that hardship is more bearable than imagined and to loosen the hold of fear on your choices.

Modern readers sometimes turn this into cold showers or fasting. Those can be reasonable personal choices, but they aren’t what the ancient texts require, and anyone with a health condition should be cautious and check with a doctor first. A gentler version is simply doing a hard but necessary task first, or going without a small convenience on purpose.

Discipline without harshness

It is easy to read discipline as severity. The Stoics were not advocates of self-punishment. Seneca describes reviewing his day each night, noting what he did wrong, and then letting himself off with an honest resolution to do better, since there was nothing in his errors to fear. The aim is accuracy and improvement, not shame. See Stoic evening reflection for a way to do this.

A related point: the Stoics weren’t claiming discipline replaces everything else. They expected people to be flexible, to use judgment and to rest when sensible. Discipline serves reason, not the other way around.

Putting it into practice

  • Decide in advance. Choose what you will do at a given time, so that you’re following a principle rather than negotiating with your mood. A morning routine is a natural place to set this.
  • Start small and repeat. Epictetus’s point about habits suggests that a modest daily act beats an ambitious one you drop.
  • Check your assent. When you feel resistance, ask what impression you are accepting. “I can’t” may really mean “I don’t want to.”
  • Review kindly. At the end of the day, note what you did, what you’d change and what you’ll try tomorrow.

For other behaviors that tend to go along with a disciplined life, see Stoic habits, and for the wider picture, how to practice Stoicism in your daily life.

The complete guide to daily living

How to Practice Stoicism in Your Daily Life
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →